Don’t forget to send in your submissions for the Carnival of Feminists!
And a brief detour into pop culture criticism. Landisdad and I finally watched Crash last night (I know, we’re huge romantics!), and I have to say, we both walked away wondering what all the hype was about. I mean, I realize it was supposed to be this big, transformative movie about race, but jeez, any episode of The Wire is more thoughtful about that subject. Part of the way through, landisdad pointed out that almost every scene consisted of two people, one of whom was invariably yelling at the other one about why she/he was a racist. Of course, it became impossible not to watch the film through that lens from that point forward. And what a shame, because some truly talented actors were utterly wasted in it. Last year, the only Oscar-nominated film I had seen was Brokeback Mountain, and I couldn’t help but be sympathetic to the outcry that it was robbed of the Best Picture Oscar–now I know that outcry was right.


8 comments
Comments feed for this article
February 15, 2007 at 9:28 pm
Kimberly
Wait…Brokeback didn’t win? What won?
February 15, 2007 at 9:45 pm
jackie
I think people thought “Crash” was so amazing because it tried to address not just white-on-black racism, but also the kinds of race & ethnicity based prejudices that can exist in anyone, regardless of race. In other words, it proposed, “Hey, we’re all racist sometimes! It’s not just white people’s faults! Colored people are racist too!”
Or at least, that was my read, and why I also thought it was overrated
.
Brokeback was indeed robbed, and yeah, the best and most complicated ongoing examination of race in this country right now is definitely “The Wire”– and I totally admit a Baltimore-bias here, but I don’t care, it’s just true.
February 16, 2007 at 2:28 am
Phil
I enjoyed Crash but, like you said, it seemed just above average… Like it was trying too hard. And the whole “connections” thing has been done better by movies like Magnolia.
Brokeback Mountain made me cry at the end. The Oscars have a history of awarding Best Picture to the Flavor of the Month instead of the films with staying power.
February 16, 2007 at 4:29 am
Lady M
I haven’t managed to see either film yet, but I’ve heard so many people rave about Brokeback. Plus, I’m an Ang Lee fan. Guess I’ll be skipping Crash.
February 16, 2007 at 9:44 am
thordora
Same here. Crash was “ok” but it seemed a little full of itself. But I found Brokeback overrated as well. But I’m not a big Ang Lee fan, so…
February 16, 2007 at 3:02 pm
Daydreams and Musings
I saw Crash last year – after the hype died down a bit. True to my somewhat apolitical nature and maybe because my love of film as an art form, I watched it more for the acting, directing, camera angle stuff than for the political statement. And from that point of view, I really liked it.
I haven’t seen Brokeback yet and it’s taking up TIVO space that needs to go to more guilty pleasures such as American Idol and Survivor. I gotta watch that movie this weekend. I could use a good cry.
For this year’s Oscars the only nominated film I’ve seen is The Departed. And for that movie, I think the hype is TOTALLY deserved. Loved it.
February 16, 2007 at 8:01 pm
Kimberly
So um, Crash won? How embarrassing…..Paul Haggis being a hometown boy and all, I imagine there was some hype about that. oops.
I still haven’t forgiven Ang Lee for The Hulk. But Brokeback cooled my firey hatred of him.
February 17, 2007 at 4:22 pm
Anjali
I liked Crash, but thought it was very overrated as well. Of course, I’m still bewildered that The Color Purple didn’t win a single Oscar in 1985. Go figure.