all changed, changed utterly

In the aftermath to Hurricane Katrina, I wrote a post about my frustration with the whole situation called “I will not yield to a politic of despair.” This is a sort of follow-up, since I’ve just finished reading Douglas Brinkley’s history of Katrina, The Great Deluge. In my original post, I posited that the history of Katrina might actually have a chance of being true, since so many of us watched it daily on the news, but that it would only happen if we demanded the truth, and didn’t let Bush and others cover it over as they so obviously wanted to do.

Watching the footage of Hurricane Katrina as it rolled out over the last week in August last year, I was changed utterly. Although I’ve always been a pointy-headed liberal, I mostly did agree with my friends on the right that the U.S. was a great country. I felt a lot of the time that it was a great country headed in the wrong direction, but I had faith that we could still get back on track. After watching thousands of my countrymen and -women struggle for survival in the aftermath of a predicted natural disaster, my belief in the U.S. was shaken to its roots.

The title of the post I wrote last year was taken from Dr. Martin Luther King’s last sermon, “Remaining Awake Through a Great Revolution.” Reading this book, I was reminded of another line of that great oratory: “It’s all right to tell a man to lift himself by his own bootstraps, but it is a cruel jest to say to a bootless man that he ought to lift himself by his own bootstraps.” Katrina left thousands of New Orleanians bootstrapless, and then added insult to injury by making them swim, crawl, float, or wheel their loved ones in a shopping cart to reach safety.

Brinkley doesn’t pull a lot of punches in the book. It is meticulously well-researched (check out the hour-by-hour timeline at the end), and while there are many everyday people lauded as heroes, none of the three major political figures (Mayor Nagin, Governor Blanco, President Bush) involved comes off particularly well. Brinkely documents a chain of bad decisions–some merely misguided (Blanco), some outright dangerous (Bush), some born out of bad faith (Nagin).

Interspersed with the bad decisions made by those at nearly all levels of government (go Coast Guard! you folks did the right thing!) are many, many personal stories of those who survived and those who didn’t. Brinkley makes a point to document not only those who died in the storm and its aftereffects, but also to chronicle what happened to some of the survivors, including some who succumbed to Katrina-related stress. I made the mistake of bringing it with me on a plane–while it’s “unputdownable,” I think I freaked out my seatmate a little by crying while reading some of the more moving chapters.

If you’re still looking for ways to help the survivors, check out this link (but act fast). If you want a great, touching read that you’ll be thinking about for days to come, check out The Great Deluge.


September 22, 2006. books for grown-ups.


  1. Jessica replied:

    LM, I love reading your posts like these because I think we can all be guilty (okay, at least me anyway) of getting so wrapped up in our own lives and our own issues that we forget….we forget about that which we are not directly affected by.

    You often remind me of what it means to be look outside your own small world and extend yourself to others – thank you.

  2. Comfort Addict replied:


    Thanks again for a book recommendation!

  3. MetroDad replied:

    Will definitely take a look at the book recommendation, LM. Thanks. By the way, have you had a chance to see Spike Lee’s documentary on Katrina? Might be some of his best filmmaking in years.

  4. Mere replied:

    I’ll have to check out that book, thanks.

    Ya know, it’s funny how some national tragedies make me love this country because of the way we come together in it’s aftermath. And yet, there are others that make me feel like we, as a country, are going down the toilet. Katrina was an all-time low when it came to my patriotism. It makes me weepy to think of the way human beings – our fellow countrymen/woman – were treated during that time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback URI

%d bloggers like this: